Arguments against egg and sperm donors
Donors should be appreciated by society for what they have done, and should take pride in any children their gift has helped to bring into the world. Many children are conceived through one-night stands and never know their fathers — should they have the right to access a DNA database of the whole male population in order to find them? The only legtitimate point of the anti-anonymity argument is that the donor might have bad genes. Through its health system and regulators, the state plays a part in donor-assisted conception. All Rights Reserved Charity No: This paper has offered an overview of gamete donation and pre-conception arrangements.
Edited by Leslie Francis
To Know or Not to Know: Using Identified or Anonymous Egg or Sperm Donors
One of these visits would be combined with a compulsory counselling session 30 minutes. Likewise, many potential donors are never recruited because their initial sample is sub-optimal. The advances in human sperm cryopreservation in the past 50 years and the creation of sperm banks have facilitated the increase in artificial insemination with donor sperm AID 1 , 2. Lastly, sperm donation procedures must be conducted such that the welfare of all participants—the donors, recipients and offspring—are all respected. Royal Commission on New Reproductive Technologies.
Sperm and Egg Donor Anonymity: Legal and Ethical Issues - Oxford Handbooks
Becoming an Egg Donor: Far from castigating Victoria, we should be applauding its bravery in leading the way. Proponents of such screening see it as a way to prevent suffering, while some critics are concerned that it is based on negative stereotypes of the lives of people with disabilities and will have the effect of devaluing individuals with disabilities. Garcia to thaw the remaining four embryos, of which two survive to blastocyst stage. Such consequences are clearly bad for everyone, being unregulated, often emotionally messy, and possibly even dangerous. The UK law gives donor children equality with adopted children, and should be followed by other countries.
Some felt that additional compensation may detract from the gift nature of donation or might affect the type of donor who chose to donate. It was noted that there is a fine line between compensation and payment, and that telling donor-conceived people that their donor had been paid might make them feel that they were in fact bought. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful. But if this rule has resulted in reluctance to donate perhaps it should be changed. Inquiry into access by donor-conceived people to information about donors, Parliamentary Paper No.